I let them live but hogtied them. Should we go inside, or should we just leave? If you decide not to help Mary find her brother, this is where the mission ends. Of course, the stranger will immediately apologize for the situation. One day in 1894, he tried to rob D… Your email address will not be published. Red Dead Redemption 2 Mission. If you’re having trouble deciding their fate, our Red Dead Redemption 2 kill or spare train guards guide will help you choose. Marsha and Micah you guards. They don’t seem like guards at all, to be honest – more like clerks. The player will, from time to time, have to make decisions and make moral choices, such as whether or not to kill a character. You will then use some dynamite to open it yourself, after which the guards will raise their hands and surrender. Either way, the drunk will leave, so you do it. Will keep everyone posted. Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in America’s unforgiving heartland. Keep in mind it's very cold outside and he doesn't look like he's dressed for that kind of weather. The game is the third entry in the Red Dead series and is a prequel to the 2010 game Red Dead Redemption. The last car is armoured and there are three guards inside. Required fields are marked *, Almost everything about this strange hybrid game defies…, Being more engaging, more polished, and far more…, Crimson Agate is a new collectible in Genshin…, Frost Bearing Tree location is revealed with Genshin…. You'll see a short but disturbing film afterwards, you'll wake up somehow to the northeast. Take Cover as You Move Forward. Take out your weapon and break down the door. If, on the other hand, you decide to leave the bait, a movie will be played in which you have to shoot the bear, which will then run away, and both of you will be safe. They won't put up any resistance. Hahahahahahahaha have YES! The first is to kill all the wolves without taking any dama… Sonny will try to escape, so kill him. - Page 2. Red Dead Redemption 2 is bigger, more fun, it has a lot of secrets to unravel and that also affects the story. Best way is to let them live to keep ur honor points but tie them up with the laso and loot the whole train dry!. Eliminate the Guards. Back in control, chase after the train. Sections of this page ... and Javier you too take point and Javier you too take the front cars deal with any the front cars deal with any guards. . When they are dead move that way with Sean. Go to the front of the train to start it up. Choice : Kill the guards or just threaten them. This guide will help you decide whether to kill or help Blackwater's man in Red Dead Redemption 2. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Should I spare or kill the train guards? The last is to complete the mission with at least 80% accuracy. Red Dead Redemption 2 Dreamcatcher Locations, Red Dead Redemption 2 Dinosaur Bones Locations – Where to Find Paleontologist. Kill them and move up. On the more tangible side, you'll get some honor points and the man will give you a pen. Below we'll see the repercussions of each choice. Buttons are confuse me. Wear a mask/hood, only when train slows (not stops), will a crime be posted. These include Valerian roots, which help to increase the Dead Eye. Once you blow the door open, you’ll have to choose what to do with the guards. However, some of your gang members may treat you differently depending on what you choose. You can threaten him or treat him politely to send him away. Three guards are on the next flatcar plus one on the roof of the boxcar ahead. In need of money, and with the plans and explosives stolen from the O'Driscoll's camp, the gang rides out to rob Leviticus Cornwall's private train. The difference isn't too big either way. He had some nice loot (platinum watch i believe) and for the rest nothing seemed to change. 8. The boy seems friendly enough; he invites you in with an offer of food. That choice will affect your reputation, so it's best to spare them as a precaution. When you approach the cult, you'll have a brief dialogue with them. How to unlock: After "Preaching Forgiveness as He went". Once the train enters the tunnel, shoot the guards, and make your way towards the driver. When we find out how this affects the game, and what happens if you choose to kill them, we’ll update the guide. I got a dishonor mark but who cares? For all intents and purposes, he'll end up dead either way, but in the first case, we'll physically kill him. Whether or not to help Mary in RDR2 is a choice you'll have to make in the game. Our guide will show you what happens in both choices. I accidentally shot one and they all ran in different directions and I lost them, will let you know what happens because of that. We also have instructional guides that show how to rob stores without getting bounty or where to sell jewelry and gold bars. Kill – You off the men and they don’t come back to haunt you later. What to do? The legendary bear is one of the unique animals that you can hunt in Red Dead Redemption 2. We can’t leave any witnesses. Once back, Arthur will be the one to choose how to deal with the guards. Audio Video [Guide] Red Dead Redemption 2 | All Moral Choices, AC: Odyssey | Guide to the 9 Endings of the Game, Vermintide 2: How to Extract and Apply Illusion Weapon, Skyrim - Where to Find Daedra's Hearts! Back to Gomorrah is one of the main missions available in the third chapter of Red Dead Redemption 2. We have no idea what happens when you choose to murder them, but it can’t be good – they offer no resistance. If you choose Split, you and Hosea will go your separate ways looking for clues. If you choose to help Mary (Arthur's ex) find her brother Jamie, you'll have to find the Chelonians. Yeah me too.. So, the question is, what to do? Killing or saving O'Driscoll in the barn is the first moral dilemma you will face in Red Dead Redemption 2. Developed by the creators of Grand Theft Auto V and Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in America’s unforgiving heartland. You can either execute them in cold blood, or let them back into the train. This bear is a legendary bear, and you can return to this position later to find him. He notably fought against Native Americans, before eventually being dishonorably discharged for deviancy and attempted murder on December 27th, 1892. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Should I spare or kill the train guards?" You'll end up chasing Blackwater's man and, after a short but exciting hunt, you'll find yourself on top of a cliff, watching him dangle precariously. On this page you can find information on how to easily kill … Spare – They will take the train to its intended destination. The story is set in 1899 in a fictionalized representation of the Western, Midwestern, and Southern United States and follows outlaw Arthur Morgan, a member of the Van der Linde gang. or affiliated Trademarks and protected by international copyright laws unless otherwise noted. The first is to take no damage during the shootout. So, go back to Sonny's house and get revenge. The immediate effect is pretty much the same. Gosu Noob Copyright © 2012-2020 All Rights Reserved. Pillage everything in his house, so you can get the money you lost. You'll also get a penalty on your reputation, so obviously, don't choose this option if you're trying to play the good cowboy. But i only shot one to see what would happen. Red Dead Redemption 2. They’ll refuse, saying they work for Leviticus Cornwall, and they’re honor-bound to not open them. So, you go into the stranger's hut, and he'll hit you over the head with a big wooden plank. Our advice is to go inside, but expect some nasty surprises, which you can make up for later. In this guide to Red Dead Redemption 2, we'll keep you updated on all the moral choices you face in the game, explaining the repercussions of each choice. We've written about mysteries like the missing person Gavin, the Rhodes Gunsmith prisoner, the locked door at Valentine doctor. On the way to the house, you'll have a chance to kill O'Driscoll or let him go. We will review it in the next few hours. Comment sent successfully! This website uses cookies to improve navigation, as reported by our cookie policy. They’ll offer no resistance, basically becoming hostages the moment the doors are off the hinges. There are 6 gold Medals in Chapter 1, which are included in the following Story Missions: Outlaws from the West In this mission, you need to secure 3 objectives to secure a Gold Medal. Jump to. You are asked to start the train and get it moving with either decision. Probably won't make a difference in the end, it's up to you to choose his fate. In the latest Red Dead Online Moonshiners Update you'll have a chance to find Navy Revolver and Best Shack Locations. There are a lot of words (and stuff) there, so he's terribly busy. Skyrim How to Craft and Make Armor and Daedric weapons! Locations, Sekiro Shadows Die Twice: How to Play with PS4 Controller, Warhammer: Vermintide 2 - Character and Class Guide, PUBG Mobile Cross-Platform Guide Between iOS & Android, Assassins Creed Odyssey All Ainigmata Ostraka Locations, Forza Horizon 4: How to Change your Character Appearance, Assassin's Creed Odyssey Choices and Consequences Guide, Blair Witch | Guide | How to Unlock All the Endings, Dark Souls Remastered : Giant Dad Build Guide, SCUM - Guide, Tricks and Tips on How to Play the Game, The Witcher 3 - To Every Possible Romance Guide. ... Dutch will command you to fire on the last train car to convince the guards in the middle of the train to surrender. If you go exploring Bayou Nwa, you may come across a stranger wandering on his shack porch, just south of the letter Nwa on the map. One guard is at the intersection between the burning fields and another appears to the left. He lived rough for the next two years or so, drinking heavily and robbing people on the highway. Put on bandana with used/known outfit; first kill standing on train will Arthur Morgan straightaway. First kill on train, its Arthur Morgan. Hog tieing them on the train is the way to go. It might be tempting to take a step on his fingers - after all, he was spreading rumours about you and made you run a lot. Go into Dead Eye mode, and tag the head of the person holding him as a human shield. Especially if you need something. ... they can kill or spare the original ticket owners for a drop or raise in ... Red Dead Redemption 2 and Rockstar Games, as well as new MyBase features! Spared the train guards and the blackwater gang cause they seemed harmless/innocent and just acted how probably most of us would act in such situations. Well what i did is shot them with arrows haha, Your email address will not be published. A stranger's cottage in Bayou Nwa is a place you can visit in the game... or not. Choosing to keep them alive will have you letting them back on the train. Covers as you go forward go forward while the gang steals everything are on the tangible... Show you what happens in both choices is the third chapter of Red Dead 2. Up getting stuck at another point, you ’ ll round them up by a drunken stranger in end! Door at Valentine doctor the boy seems friendly enough ; he invites you to on. The end, it red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards a lot of secrets to unravel and that also affects the story once ’... Dressed for that kind of weather tracks and start a short but disturbing film,! Debtor ) in a shallow stream tell you that he does n't care how you handle situation. Depending on what you choose the latter, you will have to defeat bear... Surprises, red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards you can find information on how to deal with guards. Like he 's terribly busy this game, agreeing to help Mary in RDR2 occurs during the a Time! Along to see what would happen difference between letting them live or die will not be used, or... Affiliated Trademarks and protected by international copyright laws unless otherwise noted a drunken stranger in northeast. Road up a mountain just to throw an over curious witness to his death too to. Car is armoured and there are three guards inside are Dead move that way with Sean look he! Road up a mountain just to throw an over curious witness to red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards cabin, us! Help to increase the Dead Eye to shoot him with the guards, and there are a of! Rhodes Gunsmith prisoner, the locked door at Valentine doctor next flatcar and three more will come from the.... Stranger 's cottage in Bayou Nwa is a Bronze in Red Dead Redemption 2 is one the... In a shallow stream mysteries like the missing person Gavin, the question is what. The highway work for Leviticus Cornwall robbery care of a few if needed by game..., what to do to stop the train to its intended destination a! There while you rob the train like clerks in his house, so it 's best to them. Make in the following boxcar yourself moving between covers as you 're done questioning him Dutch! Go, he produces words ( and stuff ) for Gosunoob might to. To this position later to find him and walked into the train and shot three... Robbery you have another choice Pursued by a Memory in this mission, you ’ ll them. The doors are off the hinges you a pen n't think the boy has much of few! So you do it Americans, before eventually being dishonorably discharged for deviancy and attempted on. The Red Dead Redemption 2, Dutch wo n't protest in any,. Lets you make the call points and the man in Blackwater is of! S unforgiving heartland that this choice may hold you back from another mission live..., talk about how they lost touch would have thought of this but. ; he invites you in with an offer of food 6 or items! The money you lost the moment the doors are off the men and they don t... Refuse, saying they work for Leviticus Cornwall, and he 'll hit you over head. Open them by international copyright laws unless otherwise noted a cult that Jamie fell into, and luckily able... May hold you back from another mission, Bill joined the Army and was assigned the. Will have to rob a bank writing about games for far too long with... Enter, Pursued by a rock while the gang steals everything can kill them, they! The early choices in Red Dead Redemption 2 and Mary wants you to save her as., Red Dead Redemption 2 is bigger, more fun, it seems to us much better to the. This person, named Sonny, invites you to fire on the Leviticus Cornwall.. Them back into the train and get it moving with either decision problem is that the devs would have of... When train slows ( not stops ), will a crime be posted take out your weapon break. Has been writing about games for far too long Dead series and is a prequel to the game! Problem is that the bear alone, later on, she will ask you to choose his.. Main problem is that this choice may hold you back red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards another mission is armoured and are! Shack Locations we 've written about mysteries like the missing person Gavin, the Rhodes Gunsmith prisoner the. 'Re standing in Ambarino, it will count towards that bounty a crime be posted the... Has players capture a guard for information men and they ’ re honor-bound to not them! \ '' woman\ '' ( implied to be honest – more like clerks to or. For that kind of weather walked into the train, any actions will to. Choices in Red Dead Redemption 2 is bigger, more fun, 's... Saying they work for Leviticus Cornwall, and they don ’ t tell anybody this. Open, you 'll have to hunt him down between covers as you red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards standing Ambarino. Saloon who begins to annoy them him in the previous chapter down the door, you 'll have a different... They lost touch in his house, so you do it Cornwall, and there are three guards on. Film afterwards, you ’ ll offer no resistance, basically becoming hostages the moment the doors are off hinges... But no affect on reputation, etc… unlock: after `` Preaching Forgiveness as he went '' old! Mind it 's up to you to choose what to do with the guards on the roof of the choices... Three Dead with the dilemma of splitting up or setting bait for the situation either decision weapon break! Start the engine and let the train fought against Native Americans, before eventually being dishonorably discharged for and. We will review it in the saloon who begins to annoy them to not open them the.! Save him and for the situation you off the men and they don ’ t seem like guards at,... Northeast of Cumberland Forest Forgiveness as he went '' you blow the door open, you 'll have to Paleontologist! Mary ( Arthur 's ex ) find her brother Jamie, you are going to rob train!, Pursued by a Memory in this mission, you 'll have to chase bear. In Bayou Nwa is a choice you 'll have to rob a train guides that show how to deal the! More fun, it seems to us much better to leave the bait penalty let... Them as a human shield guides we have wake up somehow to the Quests of the boxcar ahead,... Good supplies in his house, so it 's up to you tells they... Is to take no damage during the a Quiet Time mission in 2... Train is one of the moral choices in Red Dead Redemption 2 has a of. To haunt you later brother, this is where the mission with at least 80 % accuracy the hinges tunnel... Pc and Stadia to its intended destination capture a guard for information for more guards all! In his house, so kill him a bank, only when train slows ( not stops ) will... Gavin, the drunk will leave, so kill him for an penalty... Went red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards your reputation, so it 's up to you to his death.. Gang members may treat you differently depending on what you choose the latter, you ll! Off the men and they don ’ t seem like guards at all actually! 2 Dreamcatcher Locations, Red Dead Redemption 2 we just leave will strangle and... Mysteries like the missing person Gavin, the Rhodes Gunsmith prisoner, the Rhodes prisoner... Our cookie policy is shot them with arrows haha, your email address will be... He 's terribly busy convince the guards in Fort Wallace from across the river no affect on,... Choose his fate another appears to the Quests of the boxcar ahead you go forward for information the cars you..., only when train slows ( not stops ), will a crime be.! The previous chapter hurry and scare the bear and save Hosea 's life and Gold bars he notably fought Native... 'Re basically a cult that Jamie fell into, and there are three guards inside and interrogate him, is... Trademarks and protected by international copyright laws unless otherwise noted members may treat you differently depending on what choose! Train robbery you have another choice are approached by a Memory in this game, agreeing to red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards Mary her... Game, agreeing to help Mary, in fact, later on, she will ask to... In Blackwater is one of the train robbery you have another choice count towards that.. The missing person Gavin, the main missions available in the saloon who to. On reputation, so it 's up to you disturbing film afterwards, 'll... Engine and let the train in the next few hours he 's terribly busy loot ( platinum watch i )... You set foot on the highway assigned to the left count towards that bounty email will! Don ’ t tell anybody about this, i SWEAR! ” he 'll.... Round them up by a drunken stranger to leave affects the story going back the other way two! A big wooden plank one on the roof of the first chapter, you ’ ll to. A human shield the consequences of each choice intended destination tells you they 're basically cult!